The newly elected UK government is weighing the possibility of reopening talks with the European Union (EU) for a youth mobility program.
This scheme would allow people under 30 from both the UK and EU to travel, work, and live in each other's countries for extended periods.
UK may consider youth mobility scheme
A UK government source told The Times that the Prime Minister’s office is ready to listen to the EU’s proposal on the matter.
A source mentioned that, while no one is openly admitting it yet, there is a growing understanding that changes will be necessary.
This potential shift in policy comes after years of restricted movement between the UK and EU following Brexit.
The youth mobility scheme could offer new opportunities for young people on both sides of the Channel.
What youth mobility schemes offer
Youth mobility schemes, also known as working holiday visas, are agreements between countries that allow young people to live and work abroad for a year or two.
These programs typically have the following benefits:
-
Cultural exchange: Participants can experience new cultures firsthand.
-
Language learning: Living in another country provides an immersive environment for language acquisition.
-
Work experience: Young people can gain valuable international work experience.
-
Extended travel: These schemes allow for longer stays than typical tourist visas.
The UK currently has youth mobility schemes with 13 non-EU countries, including Australia, New Zealand, and Japan.
However, similar deals with EU nations have been noticeably absent since Brexit.
(Image courtesy of ktsimage via iStock)
EU’s push for youth exchanges
The European Union has been keen to establish youth mobility programs with the UK.
In April, the European Commission made a formal proposal to start negotiations for such a scheme. However, both the Conservative and Labour parties in the UK initially rejected the idea.
Despite this setback, EU member states are working on an updated proposal. They hope to develop viable negotiating points for Brussels in the coming weeks, aiming to feed into expected talks on resetting UK-EU relations.
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz has emphasized the importance of more interaction between young people in the UK and the EU.
He noted that connections between Germans and people in the UK have decreased significantly since Brexit and the COVID-19 pandemic. He believed that by improving these connections, people would understand each other better.
The German ambassador to the UK, Miguel Berger, emphasized that youth mobility is distinct from migration or free movement.
He explained, “We hear over and over the argument that [youth mobility] is freedom of movement when it is not, as it is based on visa requirements and limited time periods. People leave after a set time.”
Berger added that opportunities for young people to work as baristas or au pairs, learn languages, or do short-term training in each other’s countries create important connections.
These connections, he said, act as a “glue” between European countries.
UK government’s mixed signals
Despite the apparent openness to discussions, the UK government has sent mixed signals about its stance on youth mobility schemes with the EU.
A government spokesperson told The Guardian, “We are not considering it, there are no plans for this, or any work being done on it. Our negotiating team has very clear red lines, and none of the preparatory work involves this.”
The opposition Labour Party, led by Keir Starmer, has also taken a cautious approach to the idea of youth mobility schemes with the EU.
When the European Commission made its proposal in April, Labour quickly rejected it, likely to avoid any perception of softening its stance on Brexit-related issues.
However, Starmer’s recent meetings with EU leaders, including German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, suggest a potential shift in approach.
While maintaining firm “red lines” — including no return to free movement — Starmer has not explicitly ruled out some form of youth exchange program.
After meeting with Scholz, Starmer said they want a strong relationship that includes working together on defense, security, education, cultural exchange, and trade.
When asked about the chance of a youth mobility program, he pointed to the overall relationship between the UK and the EU.
He said, “I’m convinced that we can have a close relationship, and I think you heard from the chancellor himself, notwithstanding those clear red lines that we’ve got and we’ve always had.”
(Image courtesy of Buro Millenial via Pexels)
Challenges and opportunities for the youth
The current lack of youth mobility schemes between the UK and EU countries presents several challenges for young people:
-
Limited cultural exchange opportunities
-
Reduced options for international work experience
-
Barriers to language learning through immersion
-
Fewer chances for extended travel and living abroad
These restrictions particularly affect sectors like hospitality and tourism, which often rely on young, mobile workers.
However, the flow of young EU workers to the UK has indeed slowed since Brexit.
On the other hand, the potential introduction of a youth mobility scheme could create new opportunities. It could allow young Britons and Europeans to:
-
Gain valuable international experience
-
Improve language skills
-
Build cross-cultural understanding
-
Develop personal and professional networks across borders
Brexit impact on UK student exchanges
The discussion around youth mobility schemes has implications for the education sector, particularly universities.
The UK’s departure from the Erasmus program, which facilitated student exchanges across Europe, left a gap in opportunities for British students.
University sources have noted that student exchanges, including the Erasmus scheme, had a “return on investment” in the form of “soft power” that was never factored into Brexit calculations.
However, they also pointed out that the inclusion of a four-year study scheme in the EU’s April proposal was likely a non-starter due to the financial implications for UK institutions.
One alternative being considered at the university level is an increase in funding for EU students who want to exchange with a university in a third country.
This could help maintain educational ties between the UK and EU without the complexities of a full return to Erasmus.
(Image courtesy of Daria Kulkova via iStock)
UK split on youth mobility schemes
The debate over youth mobility schemes reflects broader tensions in UK public opinion about relations with the EU.
While many young people and businesses see the benefits of such programs, others are concerned about their impact on immigration and sovereignty.
Political parties must navigate these conflicting views carefully. The Conservative government, which led the UK out of the EU, is wary of any policies that might be seen as backtracking on Brexit promises.
The Labour Party, while generally more pro-European, is also cautious about alienating Brexit-supporting voters.
This political landscape explains the sometimes contradictory messages coming from UK politicians.
While there’s recognition of the benefits of youth exchanges, there’s also a strong desire to maintain the appearance of a firm stance on immigration and EU relations.
EU youth mobility debate impacts travel
The ongoing debate over youth mobility schemes has implications for both short-term visitors and long-term migrants to the EU.
For short-term visitors, the immediate impact is limited. UK citizens can still travel to EU countries for up to 90 days in any 180-day period without a visa.
However, the lack of youth mobility schemes restricts opportunities for extended stays and work experiences.
The upcoming launch of the European Travel Information and Authorization System (ETIAS) will introduce an additional step for UK travelers to the Schengen Area.
While ETIAS is not a visa, it will require UK citizens to apply for travel authorization before visiting ETIAS countries. This system, set to be implemented in 2025, aims to enhance security and streamline border processes for short-term visitors.
For long-term migrants, the absence of youth mobility schemes in EU countries means fewer pathways for living and working in the EU.
Young people looking to spend extended periods in EU countries may need to explore other visa options, which often have stricter requirements and may be limited to specific sectors or skill levels.
The potential introduction of a youth mobility scheme could create a middle ground between short-term visits and long-term migration.
It would allow young people to experience living and working in EU countries for a limited period without committing to long-term migration.
Influence on EU immigration policies
The UK’s stance on youth mobility schemes could influence how EU countries approach immigration deals with non-EU nations. Some potential effects include:
-
Bilateral agreements: Individual EU countries might seek to establish their own agreements with the UK, similar to the youth mobility schemes the UK has with non-EU countries.
-
Reciprocal arrangements: EU countries may reconsider their youth mobility schemes with other non-EU countries, potentially seeking more balanced, reciprocal arrangements.
-
Alternative talent attraction: Some EU countries might focus on developing different visa programs to attract young talent, possibly targeting specific skills or sectors.
-
United front: Despite individual country interests, EU member states are likely to maintain a united approach in their dealings with the UK, especially on immigration and mobility issues. This could lead to a more coordinated EU-wide policy on youth mobility with non-EU countries.
-
Review of existing schemes: The debate might prompt EU countries to review and possibly update their existing youth mobility schemes with other nations.
-
Focus on intra-EU mobility: There could be a renewed emphasis on promoting mobility within the EU for young people, to compensate for the loss of UK-EU exchanges.
The debate continues
The debate over youth mobility schemes between the UK and EU is far from over. As both sides continue to navigate their post-Brexit relationship, the issue of youth exchanges is likely to remain on the agenda.
As discussions continue, it’s clear that balancing the desires for cultural exchange and economic opportunities with concerns about immigration and sovereignty will be crucial.
The outcome of these debates will have lasting impacts on the experiences and opportunities available to young people in both the UK and EU.
While current policies limit these exchanges, the future may bring new agreements or creative solutions.
For now, young Britons and Europeans will need to explore alternative ways to experience life across the Channel, while keeping an eye on the evolving landscape of UK-EU relations.